There Have Been or There Has Been? — Which One Is Correct? — GimmeMeaning featured graphic for the article 'There Have Been or There Has Been: Which One Is Correct?'
|

There Have Been or There Has Been: Which One Is Correct?

Type there has been or have been into a search box and you meet the pair in the order your fingers hesitate over. Set out as there have been or there has been, the choice can look like a coin toss. It is not: the noun that follows the verb decides it, every time.

The opener there agrees with nothing — it simply announces that something exists or has happened. The verb looks straight past it: has been for one thing or a mass of stuff, have been for more than one.

This page settles the pair from the grammar record: the agreement rule the reference books print, the lists that bend it, the contraction that hides it, and the past form that sidesteps it altogether.

There Have Been or There Has Been? — Which One Is Correct? — GimmeMeaning featured graphic for the article 'There Have Been or There Has Been: Which One Is Correct?'

Quick Answer: In the there have been or there has been choice, the verb agrees with the noun phrase after it — never with there. There has been goes with one thing or mass: there has been a delay, there has been trouble. There have been goes with more than one: there have been delays, there have been three calls.

Understanding the Grammar Behind “There Have Been” and “There Has Been”

Start with the shape of the frame. Both phrases belong to the present perfect: has or have plus been, the past participle of be. The perfect links something that started earlier to the moment of speaking — a delay that began this morning and is still on the board, complaints that arrived last week and are still being counted.

  • ✅ There has been a change in the timetable.
  • ✅ There have been several updates this week.

The moving part is the small verb in the middle. Has is the third-person singular form; have is the form for everything plural. Been never changes. So the whole question collapses into one: is the thing you are announcing one, or more than one?

The Twist That Makes the Pair Feel Harder

And here is the twist that makes the pair feel harder than it is. The word at the front of the sentence, there, is not the subject at all.

It is a placeholder that holds the door open while the real subject — the noun phrase — arrives after the verb. The seed of every correct answer is already here: agreement runs from the verb to the noun that follows it, not to the word that opens the sentence.

The Grammar Record: What the Reference Books Actually Print

The Grammar Record — open dictionary on a stand in a library, GimmeMeaning in-article graphic for the there have been or there has been article

Start with what the reference books print, because the there have been or there has been question is settled by agreement, not by taste. Three standard authorities, checked entry by entry, give one consistent picture:

SourceWhat it printsThe line to remember
Cambridge Grammar, “There is, there’s and there are”The frame is used “when we first refer to the existence or presence of someone or something”; there is and there’s are the singular forms, there are the plural formThe frame announces existence; the number of the thing announced sets the verb
Cambridge Grammar, on the contraction“In speaking and in some informal writing, we use there’s even when it refers to more than one. This use could be considered incorrect in formal writing or in an examination.”There’s before a plural is a speech habit, not the written standard
Oxford Learner’s, “there”First sense: “there is, are, was, were, etc. — used to show that something exists or happens”; its own examples include “Has there been an accident?” and, marked informal, “There’s only four days left.”Even the dictionary’s question example runs on has there been
Merriam-Webster, “there”There is “the one to use as the first word in sentences that have the subject after the verb”The subject stands after the verb — so agreement must look there for its answer

Read the table as the verdict. No reference makes the choice turn on formality, tone or the word there itself. Each one organises the frame the same way: there opens, the noun phrase follows, and the verb agrees with that noun phrase. Singular or uncountable — has. Plural — have.

That is the same habit that settles every question of this kind: trust what the entries print over what sounds tidy. It is how the record settles perogative or prerogative too — one form entered by the books, the other not — and it is the habit this whole page follows.

What the Present Perfect Tense Really Means

The present perfect expresses a link between the past and now. It is built from has or have plus a past participle, and it suits news whose story is not finished: results that still stand, changes that still hold, experience that has piled up.

In an ordinary sentence the pattern is easy to see:

  • She has been late twice this week.
  • They have been busy all morning.

In the frame on this page, the pattern runs there + has/have + been + noun phrase — and the noun phrase at the end is where the number lives. That is the one structural fact worth memorising: the subject of the agreement is sitting at the back of the sentence, after the verb it controls.

ExampleMeaning
There has been a rise in rent.The rise began earlier and tenants are still paying it now.
There have been complaints about the noise.The complaints started before now and may not be finished.
There has been no rain for weeks.The dry spell runs from a past point right up to today.

Notice what the tense adds. “There was a rise” files the event in a finished past. “There has been a rise” keeps it live — which is why this frame is the one news reports, announcements and progress updates reach for.

When to Use “There Has Been”

Use there has been when the noun phrase that follows names one thing, or a mass that English treats as one undivided stuff.

✅ Examples:

  • There has been a problem with the booking system.
  • There has been an accident on the motorway.
  • There has been confusion about the new rota.
  • There has been damage to the roof.

Why?

Because has is the singular form of the auxiliary, and uncountable nouns — water, information, progress, damage, trouble — behave grammatically as singular. They name stuff you cannot count in ones, so the verb treats them the way it treats a single thing.

Type of SubjectCorrect FormExample
Singular nounhas beenThere has been a delay.
Uncountable nounhas beenThere has been progress.
Singular idea with a singular headhas beenThere has been something odd about the figures.

One shortcut in circulation deserves a warning. Swapping the noun for a pronoun — turning “there have been updates” into “they have been updates” — produces a sentence nobody would say, because the noun in this frame is not sitting in the pronoun’s seat.

Skip the swap test. The reliable check is duller and works every time: cover there has/have been with your thumb and read the noun that is left. One thing or a mass — has been.

When to Use “There Have Been”

Use there have been when the noun phrase that follows names more than one thing — a plural noun, a number above one, or a list joined by and.

✅ Examples:

  • There have been many reports of delays.
  • There have been several meetings this month.
  • There have been changes to the schedule.
  • There have been three calls about the leak.

Notice that the choice never turns on person in this frame. The noun phrase after been is a thing or things being announced — it cannot be I, you, we or they — so the only question the verb ever asks is how many? More than one, in any shape, takes have been.

SubjectCorrect VerbExample
Plural nounhave beenThere have been announcements.
Number phrasehave beenThere have been two resignations.
Coordinated listhave beenThere have been delays and cancellations.

If you can count the things being announced and the count passes one, the sentence belongs to have been — however formal or casual the setting is.

How to Identify the Real Subject

The trick of the whole frame is that there is a dummy. It fills the subject position so the sentence can begin, but it carries no number of its own.

Grammars call this use the existential there, the there that says something exists or has happened. The real subject, the noun phrase the verb agrees with, stands after the verb.

Test it on the pair:

  • There has been a problem. → Real subject = problem (singular)
  • There have been many issues. → Real subject = issues (plural)

So never match the verb to there. Match it to the noun phrase on the far side of been.

Example Breakdown:

SentenceReal SubjectCorrect Form
There has been an error.error (singular)has been
There have been mistakes.mistakes (plural)have been
There has been progress.progress (uncountable)has been
There have been two errors.two errors (plural)have been

“There” is a dummy word holding the front of the sentence; it never picks the verb form. The noun that follows does, and it does so whether it is a single item, a mass, or a counted crowd.

Comparing “Had Been” (Past Perfect Tense)

One step further back sits there had been — the past perfect of the same frame. It places the announcement before another past moment: the storm had already happened when we arrived; the discussions were already over before the decision landed.

✅ Examples:

  • There had been a storm before we arrived.
  • There had been discussions long before the decision.
  • There had been no warning when the bridge closed.

And had been carries a gift the present pair does not: it never changes for number. Had is the past form for every subject, singular or plural, so “there had been a delay” and “there had been delays” run on the same verb. When a sentence reaches deep into the past, the agreement question simply dissolves.

TenseTime ConnectionExample
Present Perfect (has/have been)From past to nowThere have been changes recently.
Past Perfect (had been)Before another past eventThere had been changes before we arrived.

“Had been” looks backward from a past moment to something earlier still, and it does so with a single form for both numbers.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Even fluent speakers trip over this frame, usually in the same three places.

❌ Mistake #1: Mixing plural and singular

  • Wrong: There has been many changes.
  • Right: There have been many changes.

The word many is the loudest warning sign in this pair: it only stands before plurals, so any sentence containing it belongs to have been.

❌ Mistake #2: Forgetting subject-verb logic

  • Wrong: There have been a problem.
  • Right: There has been a problem.

This is the mirror error — a plural verb left standing before a singular noun, often because the sentence was planned as a plural and edited halfway.

❌ Mistake #3: Assuming “there” controls the verb

  • Wrong: There have been confusion.
  • Right: There has been confusion.

Confusion is uncountable, so it takes the singular form — and there itself never votes either way. It has no number to impose.

✅ Quick Fix:

Ignore “there.” Read the noun phrase that follows been. Ask: is it one thing, a mass, or more than one? One or a mass — “has been.” More than one — “have been.” (A list joined by and counts as more than one in careful writing.)

Practical Examples from Real Life

Both forms run constantly through work, news and conversation. What separates them is never the setting — it is the noun each sentence announces.

ContextExample
Business“There have been several updates to our policy.”
News“There has been an increase in fuel prices.”
Daily life“There have been delays because of the traffic.”
Customer service“There has been a misunderstanding about your order.”
Education“There have been new admissions this year.”

Read down the examples and the pattern is plain: a plural announcement takes have been in a boardroom exactly as it does in a kitchen, and a singular one takes has been on the news exactly as it does in a text message.

Formal vs. Informal Use

Here is a claim worth retiring: that formal writing prefers there has been and informal speech prefers there have been. No reference book prints that split, and everyday evidence runs against it — formal reports are full of “there have been” before plurals, and casual speech is full of “there has been” before singulars.

Register does not choose the form. The subject does.

ContextPreferred FormExample
Formal writingSet by the subject — has been before a singular“There has been an error in the data.”
Informal speechSet by the subject — have been before a plural“There have been a few hiccups, but it’s fine.”

What formality genuinely changes is not has versus have — it is how much of the verb you bother to say out loud. Speech contracts.

A Quotation That Cannot Be Traced

A line often pinned on the linguist David Crystal travels with this topic: “Good grammar isn’t about rules — it’s about clarity.” The sentiment is pleasant, but the exact wording cannot be traced to anything Crystal has published — the same sentence circulates elsewhere credited to nobody at all — so treat it as a motto, not a quotation.

The checkable version needs no name behind it: agreement exists so that a reader can tell, instantly, whether you are announcing one thing or many.

There’s Been: The Contraction That Hides the Choice

In speech, the there have been or there has been choice mostly disappears — because speech shrinks there has been to there’s been, and then uses the shrunken form for everything.

“There’s been a delay” is the everyday singular. “There’s been delays” is heard just as often, and it is doing something the written language does not allow: running a singular contraction in front of a plural noun.

What the Reference Books Record

The reference books record the pattern rather than pretending it away. Cambridge Grammar notes that in speaking and in some informal writing, there’s is used “even when it refers to more than one”, and adds that the use “could be considered incorrect in formal writing or in an examination”.

Oxford Learner’s prints “There’s only four days left” and labels it, plainly, informal.

So the honest map looks like this:

  • In conversation, there’s been before a plural is unremarkable — listeners understand it as a fixed opener, not as a counted claim.
  • In careful writing, write the verb out in full and let it agree: there has been a delay, there have been delays.
  • In an exam or an application, the contracted plural is the one form on this page that can genuinely cost you marks.

The contraction is also why the written error survives. A writer who has only ever heard the pair has never heard the difference at all — has and have both vanish into the same ’s. Writing is where the choice becomes visible, and where it has to be made.

Handling Compound and Indefinite Subjects

Two subject shapes cause most of the remaining hesitation: lists joined by and, and phrases built on a singular head like one of.

Examples:

  • There have been a boy and a girl waiting. → The subject is a pair joined by and → plural → have been
  • There has been one of the students missing. → The head of the subject phrase is one → singular → has been

Look closely at the second sentence, because its reason is often mis-stated. Has been is not chosen because one is the closest noun to the verb.

It is chosen because one is the head of the phrase — the word the whole subject is built on — while of the students is a modifier trailing behind it. Agreement follows the head, wherever the head stands.

ExampleSubject TypeCorrect Form
There have been apples and oranges on the stall.Compound (plural)have been
There has been one of the cars missing since Monday.Singular head (one of)has been
There has been each of the forms signed.Singular head (each of)has been

The rule of thumb: an and-list is plural; a phrase headed by one of, each of or either of is singular, however plural the noun after of may be.

Lists and the First Noun: Where the Quick Test Bends

Now the honest complication. The quick test says “read the noun that follows” — and with a list, everyday speech reads only the first noun and stops.

That is why “there has been a fire and two floods” is heard constantly, even from careful speakers: the verb has agreed with a fire, the first item, and never travelled to the end of the list.

An Observation, Not a Rule

No reference book states that first-item pattern as a rule, and it should not be dressed up as one. It is an observation about how speech behaves under time pressure — the same pressure that produces there’s been before plurals.

Careful writing works to a stricter standard: a subject joined by and is plural as a whole, so the written form is “there have been a fire and two floods”.

Two Ways Out When a List Fights You

Two practical ways out when a list fights you:

  • Lead with the plural. “There have been two floods and a fire” puts the plural first, and both the rule and the ear are satisfied.
  • Split the announcement. “There has been a fire. There have also been two floods.” Two short sentences, each with one clean agreement.

Either way, the principle survives intact: in writing, the verb answers to the whole subject — not to whichever noun happens to stand nearest.

Expanded Verb Phrases: Using Adverbs

The frame stretches. Adverbs of frequency and time slip into the gap between has/have and been without disturbing the agreement at all:

  • There has always been confusion about that rule.
  • There have recently been many updates.
  • There has never been such excitement.
AdverbPlacementExample
alwaysBetween has/have and beenThere has always been doubt.
recentlyBetween has/have and beenThere have recently been updates.
neverBetween has/have and beenThere has never been such excitement.

The adverb rides inside the verb phrase; the number work is still done by the same two partners, has or have, chosen by the same noun as always. Nothing about the extra word changes which form you need.

Questions and Negatives: Has There Been…?

The frame turns into questions and negatives by the usual present-perfect machinery, and the agreement rule travels with it.

Questions move the auxiliary in front of there:

  • Has there been an accident? (Oxford Learner’s prints this very question under its there entry.)
  • Have there been any replies?
  • How many complaints have there been?

Negatives park not on the auxiliary, and the noun phrase usually arrives with any:

  • There hasn’t been any news.
  • There haven’t been any replies.
  • There has been no rain for weeks. (No does the negative work instead of not … any.)

Short Answers Keep the Auxiliary

Short answers keep the auxiliary and drop the rest: “Has there been an accident?” — “Yes, there has.” / “No, there hasn’t.” In every shape — statement, question, negative — the same noun is still quietly choosing between has and have.

Quick Recap Table: Has Been vs. Have Been

SituationCorrect FormExample
Singular nounhas beenThere has been a problem.
Plural nounhave beenThere have been problems.
Uncountable nounhas beenThere has been progress.
Compound pluralhave beenThere have been delays and cancellations.
One of / each of + plural nounhas beenThere has been one of the keys missing.

Shortcut Trick:
Singular or uncountable → “has been”
Plural → “have been”

Related Grammar Points

This pair sits inside a small family of frames that all run on the same engine — the verb agrees with the noun phrase that follows it.

  • “There is” vs. “There are” — the same rule in the simple present. There is a cat on the roof. There are cats on the roof. Everything on this page about real subjects, lists and contractions applies there too, one tense earlier.
  • “Has been” vs. “Was” — has been links the past to now; was files the event in a finished past. “There has been an accident” is live news; “there was an accident” is a closed report.
  • “Had been” vs. “Has been” — had been looks back from a past moment; has been looks back from this one. And had been, alone in the family, never asks how many.

All follow one consistent pattern: subject decides the verb.

Case Study: Grammar in Real Usage

Four everyday scenes, each decided by its noun:

Example 1 – Business Report:

“There have been several updates to our compliance policy since January.”
✅ Correct because “updates” is plural.

Example 2 – News Report:

“There has been an explosion downtown.”
✅ Correct because “explosion” is singular.

Example 3 – Academic Writing:

“There has been significant research on climate resilience.”
✅ Correct because “research” is uncountable.

Example 4 – Daily Conversation:

“There have been times I doubted myself.”
✅ Correct because “times” is plural.

Read together, the four scenes make the page’s whole point: the settings could not be more different — a boardroom, a newsroom, a journal, a kitchen table — and the deciding factor never changes.

Quick Quiz — a golden question mark over a small town street at dusk, GimmeMeaning in-article graphic for the there have been or there has been article

Quick Quiz

Five sentences, one decision each. Choose the form the agreement rule supports.

  1. There ___ been a sharp rise in applications this year.
  2. There ___ been three separate inquiries into the fault.
  3. There ___ been a delay and two cancellations on the northern line.
  4. There ___ been one of the laptops missing since Friday.
  5. ___ there been any progress on the claim?

Answers: 1. has (a sharp rise — singular) 2. have (three inquiries — plural) 3. have (a delay and two cancellations — an and-list, plural as a whole in careful writing) 4. has (the head of the subject is one) 5. Has (progress — uncountable, so the question takes has).

FAQs

What’s the difference between “there has been” and “there have been”?

“There has been” goes with a singular or uncountable subject — a delay, trouble, progress. “There have been” goes with a plural subject — delays, three calls. The verb agrees with the noun phrase after it, never with “there”.

Can I ever use both in one sentence?

Yes — when one sentence reports two announcements of different numbers: “There has been an increase in visitors, and there have been many positive reviews.” Each verb agrees with its own following noun.

Why can’t we say “there has been many people”?

Because “people” is plural, and “many” only ever stands before plurals. The verb must match: “There have been many people.” A has been before a counted plural is this pair’s commonest written error.

Is “there had been” still correct?

Yes. “There had been” is the past perfect: it places something before another past moment, as in “There had been trouble before the police arrived.” It never changes for number — one form serves both.

How do I know which to use quickly?

Read the noun phrase right after “been”. One thing or a mass takes “has been”; more than one takes “have been”. For a list joined by “and”, count the whole list as plural in careful writing.

Conclusion

The there have been or there has been question ends with the noun that follows the verb. One thing or a mass takes has been; more than one takes have been; and had been steps the same announcement one past point further back, with a single form for both numbers.

A line credited to Bryan A. Garner — “Good grammar is the key to clear thought” — travels with this topic, but no checkable source prints it, so treat it as a motto rather than a quotation. The rule needs no motto behind it: for the record itself, read Cambridge Grammar’s page on there is, there’s and there are.

Similar Posts

One Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *